Translation as Liturgical Extension of the Life of Synagogue and Church
Extracted text from SBL_2015.docx:
Intersemiotic Translation Yancy Smith, Society of Biblical Literature 2015 The Bible is, as Holly Hearon has suggested, simultaneously a Book and at the same time not a fixed text, between covers, that can be privately owned. If Bible is, instead, also a process of ongoing intersemiotic selection, driven by sharing, and constrained by cultural genres and practices. As a cultural icon, it also becomes, in its concrete materiality, a categorical conceptual tool by which many people organize their perceptions of the world and themselves in the world. One of my constant preoccupations is how space, time and image interact in communities to shape the interpretation of both text and image within their spaces in and out of marked, ritual time. In the third century Hippolytus, in his World Chronicle, refers to his biblical ordering of time in human history as a , a rationalized gathering of historical time-lines. But, the Chronicle unites space and time in the known world and scripturizes everything in the authors horizon. Hippolytus states the purpose: In as much as it is necessary, according to all things, to become a ready servant of the truth, I considered it necessary, my beloved brother, to make, in brief, a discourse from the holy scriptures for the purpose of the training of the love of learning in you, that through the abridged demonstrations, which we have striven over without idleness, let us, in short, seize the precise knowledge of what we research in truth out of need, in order to root out the former strife, which arises through ignorance, darkens the mind, and will instruct a person with too little learning. We then, while both eagerly loving learning and wishing to investigate these matters, will know completely, in exactness, both the division of the nations and the genealogy of the patriarchs How was the lineage of the seed of Israel fulfilled from the patriarchs to Christ? And what and how Intersemiotic Translation 1
Intersemiotic Translation Yancy Smith, Society of Biblical Literature 2015 many years of times are counted from the creation of the world until the present days? It seemed good to us, having begun from the beginning to show in brief, just as it deserves, the account not according to our own testimony, <but starting from the proved holy writings>. Therefore, taking the occasion from there, we endeavor to produce the orderly account from the Generation of Men. (Chron. 1921). For Hippolytus as well as Derrida, nothing exists outside the text.
Of course Hippolytus effort was the first spectacular Christian failures in a long line of
Intersemiotic Translation Yancy Smith, Society of Biblical Literature 2015 failures attempting to rationalize space-time and Scripture according to whatever sense contemporary science/and or historigraphy could rationalize them. In my work on Hippolytus Commentary on the Song of Songs. (Shamless plug). A corollary of his mystical (often called typological) reading of Scripture is his program of reading the Bible as the metanarrative structure of universal human history, a scripturization of all time past, present and future. When Hippolytus comments upon Scripture in the context of Christian liturgy, he is doing more than investigating texts; he claims access to the true structure of reality: of time, space, and universal human history. So he shoe-horns Roman history into a 6000 year schema as the culmination of Biblical history where the death of Christ comes about during the Passover approximately 5500 years after the Creation of the World, which means the events of the eschaton, the appearance of the Antichrist and the beginning, perhaps, of a millennial reign lies a little less than two centuries in the future. (This was a modification of some previous schemes that put the eschaton in the waning years of the 2nd century). The precise calculation and celebration of Passovers was important in this scheme because through the celebration of fasting and feasting around the complex of initiatory rites like baptism and anointing the community enacted its participation in cosmic events that marked the approach of a new world of human flourishing under divine blessing, while delaying it long enough to allow peaceful coexistence within the Roman Empire.
Intersemiotic Translation 3
Intersemiotic Translation Yancy Smith, Society of Biblical Literature 2015
Figure 1 Statue of Hippolytus
The Hippolytan community commemorated the great learning of their leader(s) with this statue, which was originally the statue of a female with an uncovered right breast and only in the 16th century fitted with a male head and properly covered as befitting a bishop. The statue itself does not directly reveal his identity. However, the image of a woman seated on a throne holding a book and representing the Church is a well-known Christian image in the popular Roman Christian text, the Shepherd of Hermas (Vis. 1.2:2; 2.8:12). On the back of the image was a list of written works thought to be associated with Hippolytus and in the hand of the image was, apparently, the representation of a book.
Intersemiotic Translation Yancy Smith, Society of Biblical Literature 2015 The community set up the statue with a calendar calculating consecutive Passovers from the first year of Alexander Severus reign, perhaps a hopeful nod toward cozy relations between
Intersemiotic Translation 5
Intersemiotic Translation Yancy Smith, Society of Biblical Literature 2015 the community and the imperial family.
Intersemiotic Translation Yancy Smith, Society of Biblical Literature 2015
Intersemiotic Translation 7
Intersemiotic Translation Yancy Smith, Society of Biblical Literature 2015
Unfortunately, Hippolytus calculations both as to the relationship of Roman time and biblical chronology as well as his meticulous calculations of Passovers based on an 8 year cycle were wildly inaccurate and very soon it would have been apparent that the whole calculation needed to be scrapped. Hippolytus was exiled and executed the same year that Alexander Severus was killed in a coup led by Maximinius Thrax.
Still, liturgies are instantiations of intersemiotic translations of Bible and that Bible becomes a conceptual principal to organize the world also a process of ongoing intersemiotic selection, driven by sharing, and constrained by cultural genres and practices.
Intersemiotic Translation Yancy Smith, Society of Biblical Literature 2015
A the Synagogue wall paintings representing a selection of Bible episodes in the Synagogue at Dura Europos witnesses of a comparable type of intersemiotic translation surrounding the Torah niche. The representations themselves bear witness to a world view that can only be experienced and expressed through, or in relation to, embodied social rituals of ultimate concern, or liturgies. These, along with the use of symbolic spaces, materials, gestures, and iconography are the means by which ancient Jews and Christians scripturize their worldhow they attempted to shape life and self-understanding in relation to scriptures through rituals of performance of these. Such rituals are formative for identity [in that they] inculcate particular visions of the good life, and do so in a way that means to triumph over other ritual Intersemiotic Translation 9
Intersemiotic Translation Yancy Smith, Society of Biblical Literature 2015 formulations (James K.A. Smith, Desiring the Kingdom).
The particular selection of Bible representations chosen to surround the holy niche in which the Torah scroll rested features honor for Jews and, largely, stories of dishonor and death for Gentiles. In other words, they would have made Jews feel proud and outsiders unwelcome, perhaps. (Or motivated to become Jews.)
Intersemiotic Translation Yancy Smith, Society of Biblical Literature 2015
The niche of the Torah shrine is topped by a frieze representing symbols of the temple itself, the sacrifice of Abraham, which according to tradition took place on the very spot where the temple would later be erected, the menorah and the tent of Abraham where the patriarch received the revelation that he would have descendants as numerous as the stars of the sky.
Intersemiotic Translation 11
Intersemiotic Translation Yancy Smith, Society of Biblical Literature 2015
Surrounding the niche are multiple scenes in which Jews are honored or triumph over their gentile antagonists.
Intersemiotic Translation Yancy Smith, Society of Biblical Literature 2015
Some of the images represented in the baptistery room are disputed. Are the women carrying myrrh to the tomb of Jesus? Or are they the wise virgins who prepared for the nuptial ceremony? (Probably the latter). Featured behind the baptistery is the Good Shepherd representation. On the sides, the healing of the lame man; and next to the baptistery on the right, upper register, the scene of Jesus and Peter walking on the water, among others.
Intersemiotic Translation 13
Intersemiotic Translation Yancy Smith, Society of Biblical Literature 2015
Intersemiotic Translation Yancy Smith, Society of Biblical Literature 2015
Intersemiotic Translation 15
Intersemiotic Translation Yancy Smith, Society of Biblical Literature 2015
Intersemiotic Translation Yancy Smith, Society of Biblical Literature 2015 Not pictured here, but present at the exit (or entrance) to the baptistery are the anointing of David and the victory of Samson over Goliath.
Baptism itself is a performance of Bible, deeply evocative of a whole range of texts and relationships. The liturgy of Baptism is a way for believers to enact a participation in the lavish participation in grace for the baptizand, thus also enacting union with Christ as well as union with the church and the holy saints of Bible and successive generations of saints. Is this liturgical participation also Bible? Is the performance of Bible here in the community and identity forming enactment a way of scripturizing the life of the believer and embodying the text in life, the translation of experience in intersemiosis? Intersemiotic Translation 17
Intersemiotic Translation Yancy Smith, Society of Biblical Literature 2015


0 comments
Sign in to join the conversation.