MAP — Modular Aggregation of Principles for Bible Translation

Dear all:

This article https://www.christianitytoday.com/ct/2022/june-web-only/pentecost-bible-translation-holy-spirit-language.html on the occasion of Pentecost, Bible translation and the Translation Insights and Perspectives tool was just posted by Christianity Today.

Happy Pentecost,

Jost

Extracted text from https://www.christianitytoday.com/ct/2022/june-web-only/pentecost-bible-translation-holy-spirit-language.html:

TypeError: undefined is not an object (evaluating 'window.abtasty.send')

https://www.christianitytoday.com/ct/2022/june-web-only/pentecost-bible-translation-holy-spirit-language.html:27 in setUserStatus https://www.christianitytoday.com/ct/2022/june-web-only/pentecost-bible-translation-holy-spirit-language.html:37 in onload WARNING ID:1 MESSAGE: false is wrong type, must be boolean, using default value instead

https://d29usylhdk1xyu.cloudfront.net/manifest/login:share?version=final:129 in show Jump directly to the Content

Explore WHO WE ARE WHAT WE DO NEWSLETTERS GIVE NOW

How Do You Translate Filled with the Holy Spirit? Pentecost let everyone hear the gospel in their first language. Bible translators work to give others that intimate experience too. JOST ZETZSCHE|JUNE 3, 2022

Image: Illustration by Mallory Rentsch / Source Images: WikiMedia Commons SHARE TWEET SHARE LINK EMAIL PRINT Pentecost reveals a God who understands that language is more than communication.

Just days after Jesus death and resurrection, the Holy Spirit arrives, and with him, the apostles ability to speak in other languages. Diasporic visitors from as far away as todays Iraq, Libya, and Italy suddenly can hear the gospel in their mother tongues. Hearing about Jesus in this intimate way surprises and amazes the listeners in Jerusalem and viscerally reinforces the personal nature of Jesus mission. (The fact that these visitors likely understood Jerusalems prevailing languages of Greek or Aramaic further underscores this.)

Yet the church was slow to adopt this message of Pentecost when it came to translating Scripture. Yes, they used translated the Bible, but predominantly into Latin, Koine Greek, Ge'ez, Coptic, or Church Slavoniclanguages that, over time, became the domain of just a few.

This first changed during the Reformation, and then again with the advent of Bible societies in the 19th century and with translation organizations such as Wycliffe Bible Translators in the 20th century. Today, more than 3,500 languages have at least a portion of the Bible translated into their language (a huge jump from about 2,000 languages just 20 years ago!).

The explosion of modern Bible translations amplifies the ongoing story of Pentecost, a grace that becomes most apparent when were able to unearth the riches of these translations and share their treasures beyond their original target audiences.

A couple of those gems can be found in Acts 2:4, the verse that reports on the lifting of that language barrier: They were all filled with the Holy Spirit. Then they began to speak in other languages which the Holy Spirit made them able to speak (NLV).

Holy Spirit or Holy Ghost?

Since 1885, the year of the first major revision of the King James Version, all major English Bible translations have used the term Holy Spirit, and yet the older Holy Ghost has maintained its enormous staying power. Practical reasons include the continued use of the original King James Version (KJV) and the use of Holy Ghost in nonbiblical texts, including The Doxology. But it also reveals the stubbornness of languageand language speakers.

Of course, there is nothing wrong with Holy Ghost as a termwhich brings us to a second insight. English has built its vocabulary by rather unashamedly borrowing from many languages, creating sometimes fascinating constellations of synonyms. Ghost comes from the Old English gst, which originally meant breath or good or bad spirit, and spirit comes from the Latin spiritus, which means breath or supernatural immaterial creature.

10 Biblical Terms I Wish Christians Had in English How the languages of the indigenous in Panama, a community in Siberia, and people in Papua New Guinea shape their understanding of God. JOST ZETZSCHE So why did the 19th-century revisers of the KJV change ghost to spirit when they used to mean essentially the same thing? In the revisers opinion, ghost had transitioned to refer too strongly to the spirit of a dead personperhaps in response to the popularity of Victorian mediums and seancesthus running the risk of implying that the Holy Spirit was the haunting ghost of a deceased god.

If language changes over time and you have a treasure chest like English, why not adjust? Other languages with more limited vocabularies didnt have that same freedom, so German, Dutch, and Afrikaans, for instance, still use a form of ghost today (Geist, Geest, and Gees, respectively).

Holy Spirit: he, she, or ?

Many languages use grammatical genders that should not be confused with biological genders, especially because the genders for identical terms can vary so much from one language to another (like the word sun, which has the grammatically feminine gender in German and the male in Spanish, and the word moon, which is the opposite in the respective languages).

Article continues below

Free Newsletters Get the best from CT editors, delivered straight to your inbox!

This form is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. MORE NEWSLETTERS But if the biological gender is inherently necessary for a noun (man, woman, bull), in most cases it matches the grammatical gender. This becomes complicated with Spirit, however, where the original languages use the neuter term Pnema in Greek and the feminine word ruach in Hebrew.

Before A.D. 400, Classical Syriac (also known as Syrian Aramaic), a language related to Hebrew, used a termRuhthat required a feminine grammatical gender. Around 400, however, a change started to emerge. When referring to the Holy Spirit, Spirit was now construed as masculine, even though it was contrary to the rules of the language (wind or lower-cased spirit continued to require a feminine gender). In this case, the language speakers seemed to have complied with the grammatical violation.

Other language speakers were not as compliant. In Ashninka, for example, a language spoken in Brazil and Peru, the term for spirit began as feminine and was artificially changed to masculine for the Holy Spirit. Ashninka speakers simply refused to accept the change in practice, however, and the Bible translators were eventually forced to change it back to its true grammatical gender. Upon further research, though, the translation team failed to detect any perceptible difference in the speakers understanding of the nature of the Holy Spirit.

For some languages, the classification of nouns goes beyond gender. In Bantu languagesa very large language family spoken in Central and South Africanouns belong to between 15 and 18 different classes. In Swahili, the word Roho for Spirit should have been in the noun class for loan words (traveling to Swahili via Arabic), but early translators felt it was too risky to have Spirit be misunderstood as an inanimate object. So although it was grammatically incorrect, they placed Roho in the first class of nouns specifically reserved for peopleand Swahili speakers accepted it.

In the case of Lamba, another Bantu language, the translators did not want to take any such liberties. Umupasi Uswetelele, Lambas term for Holy Spirit, belonged linguistically to the noun class also used for trees and plants, making it a non-person, grammatically speaking. And that's where it remains today. But its meaning is apparently unambiguous because, according to linguist C. M. Doke, numerous references in the Scriptures establish that the Holy Spirit is a person, the third person of the Trinity.

A recent example of the intersection between language and theology is in a language with a long tradition in Bible translation. Swedish used to have three genders (masculine, feminine, and neuter), but modern Swedish uses only two genders (common [utrum] and neuter). Until the Bibel 2000, Holy Spirit was translated as helige Ande, which is masculine. With the merging of the masculine and feminine genders into the common gender, it is now translated as the common-gendered heliga ande, matching the more widely used gender-equal-language practice in Sweden.

So whats the bottom line with Holy Spirit and gender? Certainly, the Holy Spirit transcends our distinctions of male, female, or whatever other kind of classification a language might offer.

Translating Holy Spirit in traditionally non-Christian cultures

The late Eugene Nidaa towering figure in the history of Bible translation and linguistics who was highly respected in secular academiasaid in regard to languages without any Christian tradition, Undoubtedly no word has given quite so much trouble to the Bible translator as spirit. Although this quote dates back to 1961, the difficulties in finding the right term continue in the ongoing encounter between Christianity and new cultures.

Article continues below

Myriad stories exist where these translation struggles and successes are the direct result of initial failures. One such was the translation of Holy Spirit into Ditammari of Togo as pure aira term Christian translators used to delineate from impure air, which in traditional beliefs refered to unclean spirits. Early Bible readers misunderstood this as the air that we breathe, so translators eventually changed it to air of God.

Another wonderful translation is Biyax Utux Baraw or Power of God in Seediq (spoken in Taiwan). I especially like the translation choice made in Western Highland Chatino (spoken in the Mexican state of Oaxaca). Here, Holy Spirit is rendered as Tyi'i Ndiose or Gods perfect heart, a description that touches my heart (imperfect as it may be).

When examining linguistic choices like this, its important to keep in mind that they were not made by the translation team because they had the most exotic and exciting ring to them. Rather, their research showed that other word choices, even those that seemed to be more immediate matches, had connotations that would be confusing at best or misleading at worst.

Filled with the Holy Spirit

The first sentence of Acts 2:4 includes these words in most English translations: filled with the Holy Spirit. I have spoken to fellow Christians who confided in me that they don't really know what this means. Yes, they believe in God the Father. They believe that he sent Jesus, his Son, to die on the cross for our sins, and that by believing in him they can have everlasting life.

But the Holy Spirit? They believe in him as far as Scripture testifies about him, but they havent experienced the Spirits presence in their lives. Theyre not even talking about ecstatic experiencessimply the assurance that the Holy Spirit lives within them, or that they are filled with the Holy Spirit.

Words are keys to defining our world. Especially with something as intangible and yet experiential as being filled with the Spirit, it might be of tremendous help to those who are not sensing the Holy Spirits presence in their lives to use a different metaphor. While all languages are completely capable, they describe perceptions of reality in slightly different ways.

And what may seem to be a limitation may open unique opportunities. For example, as Nida attests in the 1972 Handbook on the Acts of the Apostles: In many languages people are not regarded as empty, [and can therefore not] be filled.

Bible translations in languages with this limitation have discovered a treasure trove of alternative descriptions for the Spirits activity in human beings (as you can see here) including the Spirit filling ones heart (Yamba, spoken in Cameroon) or the Spirit filling ones head and heart (Isthmus Mixe), the Holy Spirit coming to be completely with one (Rincn Zapotec, which with Isthmus Mixe are spoken in Oaxaca, Mexico), and walking with the Holy Spirit (Eastern Highland Otomi, spoken in central Mexico).

My favorites come from two unrelated languages in Peru. The Shipibo-Conibo translators chose the Holy Spirit permeates one (as medicine), and the Yanesha translators employed wear the Holy Spirit, because for them filling didnt make sense. Wearing fit better in their traditional belief system.

Article continues below

What should our response be to alternate translations like these? We can either examine them as linguistic curiosities, or we can allow them to probe our own imperfect heartsto see whether they can help us grow. We may recognize that we might very well wear the Holy Spirit, that we might walk with the Spirit, that the Holy Spirit comes to be completely with us, that the Spirit permeates us as much as a medicine that dissolves in our bloodstream and enters every nook and cranny of our body.

Gods cup of grace overflows in his continuation of the Pentecost miracle through Bible translations in thousands of languages. And when reverse-translated into English, these versions have the power to open our eyes and astonish us, much like those first listeners in Jerusalem.

Jost Zetzsche is a professional translator who lives on the Oregon coast. Since 2016 he has been curating United Bible Societys Translation Insights and Perspectives (TIPs) tool. His latest book is Encountering Bare-Bones Christianity.

BIBLE Gained in Translation Having the Bible in our own language is a gift we shouldn't take for granted. JONATHAN DOWNIE

Reply on Twitter Join in on Facebook Follow us on Instagram Share on Telegram TAGS: Bible Translation | Pentecost POSTED: June 3, 2022 MORE FROM: Jost Zetzsche Current Issue MAY/JUNE 2022

SUBSCRIBE The Scottish Complementarians Who Teach Women to PreachAs for Me and My Household, Well Resist MammonSecularism Doesnt Have to Be Bad READ THIS ISSUE

Subscribe to Christianity Today and get access to this article plus 65+ years of archives. Home delivery of CT magazine Complete access to articles on ChristianityToday.com Over 120 years of magazine archives plus full access to all of CTs online archives Learn more SUBSCRIBE NOW Already a subscriber? Log in Read These Next

TRENDING

PUBLIC THEOLOGY This Is the Southern Baptist Apocalypse The abuse investigation has uncovered more evil than even I imagined. RUSSELL MOORE ESPAOLPORTUGUSFRANAIS FROM THE MAGAZINE

COVER STORY Our Pulpits Are Full of Empty Preachers Tens of thousands of pastors want to quit but havent. What has that done to them? KYLE ROHANE FRANAIS RELATED

NEWS Bible Gateway Removes The Passion Translation Popular among charismatics, the heart-level Bible version was criticized as a paraphrase posing as translation. KATE SHELLNUTT EDITOR'S PICK

ONWARD Tribalisms Awful Antidote Were made to have a herd. Made to transcend it, too. RUSSELL MOORE

This form is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

GIVE TODAY Who We Are What We Do Stories How to Partner Careers Media Room Follow Us Privacy Policy & Cookies Terms of Use Advertise Help Contact Us My Account 2022 Christianity Today - a 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization. https://www.christianitytoday.com/ct/2022/june-web-only/pentecost-bible-translation-holy-spirit-language.html

Article on Pentecost and Bible translation in Christianity Today

0 comments